Home News Welsh Blogs The Grapes of Roath

 

When Slugs Attack!

Posted by SuperDave on May 10, 2007 6:56 PM | 

It looks like the coming month is going to be dry and warm. Personally I have a hunch that the whole summer will go down in history as one of the hottest and driest (I only say this to guarantee a plentiful supply of rain for my allotment). This means, in my experience, that there is a good chance slug activity will be limited this year and the following advice will be useless. But we shall see.

I started writing this blog entry about one week ago. True to form my confident predictions have fallen foul of the fickle finger of fate. This isn't to say the rain is unwelcome, it's just that the timing could be better. A good solid downpour for 3 hours every Tuesday and Thursday afternoon and between 2.30 and 5.30am on a Saturday night would be perfect. It would also allow easy acquisition of taxi's after binge drinking and suitable punishment for overdoing it. Clearly this is too much to ask for and we now have a relatively warm and extremely wet Cardiff.


Legions of slugs will be on the rise, eager to get their greasy radulas all over your tender lettuce seedlings. These are the armies the Colonel would do well to focus his efforts on. They move silently, under cover of darkness or in the damp grey swirl of a British summer. They decimate your crops then fade into the dark dankness of the netherworlds. Seemingly motionless and bloated with green they vanish into the ether like an army of xerophobic vegetarian vampires morphing into the dark night. They are the bringers of frustration and bare earth where once was green and full of potential. They cannot be defeated. They are death incarnate.


Anyway! Here's my top ten tips for dealing with slugs.


I have tried many of these methods myself, some I have even, frequently, tried on myself. Auto-experimentation has got me drunk and kept me regular and I highly recommended it. But for now all these methods should be targeted at slugs.

1. Beer - The basic theory here is that slugs love beer. This seems like a reasonable premise to me and is the one characteristic that allows me to afford them a scintilla of sympathy. You can either buy a purpose made beer trap or purposely make one yourself. All you need to do is half bury an appropriate container in the ground (a beer glass shaped object would be appropriate) with about 3cm of rim standing proud above the soil surface. Fill it with beer, cheap beer, and if you're feeling particularly vindictive you can toss a bit of salt in there too. The slugs will sniff the beer, gatecrash the party, get drunk (in my mind at least) and drown in the heady brew to be emptied out by you the following day. The raised lip will prevent useful predators, such as beetles, from falling into the beer. A messy and unpleasant option but can be effective as long as you regularly empty and replenish the container. Be sure to cover the trap on rainy days, leaving space for slugs to enter, to reduce the risk of dilution. The slimy grimness can be added to the compost heap (but not with salt).


2. Bran - Not so sure about this one, haven't tried it. Apparently slugs also love bran. If you scatter it around your seedlings the slugs will go for the bran and bloat themselves up nicely for the birds to pick off. If you keep very still you can spend many a happy hour watching thrushes wiping the defensive slime off slugs before swallowing them whole!


3.Pellets - I use Growing Success Advanced Slug Killer, and no other. It is safe for wildlife, cats dogs, children etc and seems to do the trick. Read the instructions and do what they say. I never use the blue pellets as these can harm natural slug predators which is clearly stupid.


4. Physical violence (covert) - For the truly vindictive gardener. Go out at night when slugs are on the prowl with a sharp stick and torch. Hunt them down and spear them, leave their rotting carcasses for the birds to eat. If your allotment backs on to houses this can get you arrested so full SAS tactics are recommended. Not Andy McNabb tactics though.


5. Physical violence (devious) - To avoid lengthy explanations to the local constabulary try this method of direct slug targeted violence. Leave apparently pleasant daytime shelters around the allotment, planks of wood, damp old newspapers (leave them folded so they don't blow away), grapefruit halves, a layer of cabbage leaves are all suitable havens for slugs. Each morning lift them up and kill all slugs found using what ever method you see fit. The law can't touch you!


6. Biological agents - Specifically, in this case, nematodes. Mogg swears by these and has used them successfully for several seasons, hopefully he will confirm this. These microscopic angels of slug doom love to eat slugs from the inside, and even better they love wet weather just as much as slugs do. They can be bought online from many suppliers, I won't express a preference as I've yet to try them (but might give them a go on my potatoes later in the year - I will keep you informed). I suspect the prices are dropping year on year and can confirm that I've seen them for a Pavarotti (a tenor...tenner, geddit? ah hehe), so bear that in mind while browsing.


7. Good housekeeping - Keep your plot free of weeds and debris that slugs can also feed on and hide under (devious violence methods excluded). The best way to do this is with a good hoeing once a week. Well hoed soil will have a good fine tilth on the surface which slugs don't really like to crawl over that much, they prefer a nice flat surface that doesn't soak up too much slime. Obviously this is good allotment practice anyway so everyone is a winner, apart from Mr Slug, bless his cotton sock.


8. Predators - If you can achieve this there are many dividends. I suspect slugs taste disgusting, but this is not an opinion shared by all of natures creatures. Hedgehogs, frogs, toads and newts, thrushes and redwings, shrews, slow worms, centipedes, beetles, ducks and hens, to name a few, all like nothing better than to feast on a nice juicy slug. So encourage these chaps into your allotment. Make a hedgehog friendly nest box, build a small pond for frogs and newts, never ever use poisonous slug pellets. Get some ducks and chickens, if it's for the allotment get permission first. At worst you will have a few more animals to watch during your rest periods and a green glow of smug satisfaction. At best you'll have eggs and fresh duck breast for supper!

9. Strong healthy plants - Both slugs and plants have been around for millions of years. The slugs are still here and the plants are still here, so it's not a one sided battle. Once your plants have got past seedling stage they can pretty much stand up for themselves, the slugs will still have ago, and make a living for that matter, but the plants will be strong enough to outgrow the slugs several times over. So make sure your soil is healthy and full of nutrients, bring your children up on a healthy diet and they grow into healthy adults able to deal with the stresses of every day life. It's not rocket science.


10. Various other useful and hair brained schemes that I don't have time to go into

Coffee grounds - Get a bin bag full from your local coffee shop and scatter.
Hair - Local barbers, as above (coffee and hair both good for the soil).
Don't grow plants that slugs eat - As if!
Sharp sand / gravel - Pointy! Slugs don't like it...ouch, ooh, ah, ooch, eek!
Crushed egg shells - see above.
Copper strips - a bit like electric fences for slugs.
Water in the mornings - that's a good point actually.
Salt on the soil - Come on now, that's just stupid, unless you're planning to grow seaweed.


I am more than happy to update this with any new suggestions, so let me know.

And happy hunting!



 

Comments (15)

wilbach wrote...

kill kill kill kill...

SuperDave replies...

Exactly!

Posted by: wilbach  | May 12, 2007 8:32 PM

The Colonel wrote...

SuperDave,
I overestimated you. I had high hopes for you but now fear that you are firstly oblivious to the impending emergency and secondly that you lack the calibre I had assumed of you. Whilst you may make this choice for yourself, I would be grateful if you could pass my details to the girl Louise that she can decide her own destiny.
Further to your tirade about our totalitatianism, it is true that unity will be important in the inital period following the breakdown, the Council of the BLADE is determined to restore the lost liberties of Albion. Totalitarianism is our antithesis. Blood may be shed in the process but the blood will cleanse these ancient soils from which a brave new nation can emerge.
So farewell SuperDave, I wish you no harm and I hope you do not regret your choice.

SuperDave replies...

Fear not Colonel, you're not the first person to overestimate me.

Regarding my choice...

"The man who insists upon seeing with perfect clearness before he decides, never decides. Accept life, and you must accept regret." Henri-Frédéric Amiel (1856)

and regarding the cleansing of the soil...

"Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed." Genesis ix. 6.

We have followed the path to blood so many times yet still history repeats itself, will we ever learn I wonder.

Farewell Colonel, I truly hope your prophecies never come to pass. I will direct Louise to your communications and let her make her own choices.

Posted by: The Colonel  | May 14, 2007 1:32 PM

The Dark One wrote...

Well well well.. Scarey comment by The Colonel, he obviously ate his Weetabix drizzled in Omega-3 yesterday.

I'm all for a slug war, they are disgusting and pointless and should DIE!

SuperDave - what are your thoughts on destroying the ant population that seem to have invaded my patio?

SuperDave replies...

Hi Dark One, welcome to the show!

While I rejoice in your hatred for the one footed vandals of the garden I'm beginning to wonder, in the interests of fair play, if anyone out there is prepared to defend the evild slime demons. Anyone?

Ants on the patio are a little outside my remit but here goes. Firstly are they red? If so approach with extreme caution and prejudice because they are surprisingly vicious and painful. They're also known as fire ants, and with good reason. I was attacked by them last year after accidentally digging up a nest. I paid them no heed and carried on digging. Big mistake. Taking umbrage at my casual vandalism they launched an assault that resulted in me running away slapping my ankles in some bizarre reenactment of the Morcambe and Wise end of show dance. They bite and then they sting with a toxic alkaloid venom which feels like hot fat spattering against the skin, with no promise of a bacon sandwich to follow. So beware.

Black ants, in the allotment at least, are major pests and will actually farm and defend aphids on susceptible plants. I had a major infestation on my broad beans last year which proved impossible to completely eradicate. On the plus side it was fascinating to watch them move aphids about, defend them from all predators, including me, and eventually see them milking nectar from the aphids bottoms. Lovely.

On the patio there is one easy answer for quick control when they are out in force. Boiling water will see them rapidly, and humanely, washed away to oblivion. Unfortunately this will not get rid of the nests which will be safely ensconced under the patio slabs. To deal with the nests I recommend (from childhood memory) a product called Nippon. It's a tasty looking gel (don't taste it) that the ants take back to the nest and share out. It should destroy a colony in 7 to 10 days, apparently. So pop out to the local hardware store and give it a try.

I hope this helps oh Dark One. I would hate to think of you sitting on your patio being dominated by these marauders instead of enjoying your Pims and olives.


Posted by: The Dark One  | May 15, 2007 6:56 PM

Switch Chick wrote...

I've just looked at your site for the first time SuperDave and I have to say it's the best, most informative and sexiest blog I've ever read. Keep up the good work!

SuperDave replies...

Well thank you Switch. And you can confirm that we've not related and have never met before?

Posted by: Switch Chick  | May 16, 2007 3:37 PM

German Jo wrote...

Awesome blog. Extremely useful and informative....

Has anybody mentioned the effectiveness of 'Salt' in relation to slugs?

SuperDave replies...

Thanks very much Jo. Salt is great for dealing for slugs, if a little sadistic. Be careful using it on the allotment though unless you plan to grow salt tolerant plants.

I have to say wherewhatwhen.co.uk looks pretty good too. Clean, easy on the eyes and uncluttered. I suspect I will be using it in the future!

Posted by: German Jo  | May 16, 2007 6:54 PM

Mike the German wrote...

Decent enough blog...

What about the effect of 'Salt' on slugs??

Answers on a postcard please...

SuperDave replies...

I play football with a German Mike... could this possibly be the same person??? He's not German, it's a long story.

Re Salt, please see my reply to GermanJo!

Posted by: Mike the German  | May 16, 2007 6:56 PM

SuziQ wrote...

Gutted that slugs had been rampaging through my tiny greenhouse, I trawled the web looking for solutions.
Not only can I go and try out some new ideas, but the comic descriptions cheered me up no end. I'm still sitting here giggling.

SuperDave replies...

Glad I could be of use Suzi. If ever you need to know anything just drop me a line and I may dedicate a blog entry to you.

And it makes me very happy to know I've created a giggle.

Posted by: SuziQ  | May 17, 2007 3:04 PM

Louise wrote...

Hi SuperDave,
Thanks for your mails! It's going to be a lovely weekend and I'm dedicating it all to my plot and to my suntan of course!!! Who is the colonel?! A bit scary but you can give me his details...I might quite enjoy being used to re-populate the world but I don't think I'll tell him I'm on the pill!!!!
Lxx


SuperDave replies...

Details passed on Louise. Hope your tan isn't getting too damp this weekend.

Keep me informed of the plan to save the world!

Posted by: Louise  | May 23, 2007 10:52 AM

German Jo wrote...

SuperDave - Thanks for your encouraging words of wisdom RE Wherewhatwhen.co.uk

I have recently been invaded by snails!
Advice on how to get rid of? Humanely if possible?

Up the 'Germans'

Jo the German

P.S - My bamboo is sprouting everywhere (from the original mother plant).
Not too sure whether to let it do it's own thing or go on a bamboo 'Cull'?

I could always buy a Panda?


SuperDave Replies.....

Wow, several points to deal with.

1. WhereWhatWhen.co.uk You're very welcome, particularly so as you describe my words as wise!

2.Snails - A similar range of defenses used against slugs will also work on snails, with the following points to note...

Snails are more easily able to move over dry land than slugs, largely due to their shells reducing water loss.

Nematodes are less effective on snails. Nematodes work at their best withing the soil below the surface. Snails, once again with their protective shells, spend very little time, if any, under the soil surface and are therefore less susceptible.

Unlike slugs, snails enter a dormant period over winter when they can be hunted down in dark damp places, or laid out on the lawn fro the thrushes to eat. Make sure you have a few convenient stones around the garden for the thrushes to use as an anvil.

I rather like snails, with their attractive shells, and generally they are less destructive than slugs. They are essentially slugs with caravans, and we all know how conservative and respectful of the country code caravan owners are. Shame they're not a bit more respectful of the twenty cars cued up behind them as they amble down country lanes (that's caravans I'm talking about now).

3. Given that not a single German made it to football tonight and I had to field a whole new team I have to wonder how up the Germans I should be. By popular agreement they actually don't like it up 'em you know.

4. Bamboo. Assuming it's the big bamboo that my brother in law grows in France I suggest you cultivate it then pass it on to grateful allotment owners as a runner bean support. Otherwise dig it out and replant it in a container with the bottom cut off (a dustbin say, buried in the ground) to prevent it spreading.

5. Pandas. From what I've heard pandas have gone through a sexual reawakening recently and are breeding like crazy. If you're not careful you might end up with a growing panda family, but at least they would keep the bamboo under control.

Hope this helps.

Up the reds!

Posted by: German Jo  | May 30, 2007 8:35 AM

German Jo wrote...

Some Slug Research. Hope you find it useful. I'm thinking of getting some chickens very soon...

Slugs Problems

The Garden Advice guide to controlling slugs and snails in your garden.

There are 24 different species of slug in Britain, about half of which can be found in the garden. Most slugs eat decaying vegetation, but readily switch to young or delicate plants, feeding on the leaves, stems, roots and tubers. They evolved from snails and in the course of doing so lost all, or most of their shell. All slugs are hermaphrodite, that are they have both male and female sex organs. Mating and cross-fertilisation is the norm, but every individual produces the spherical translucent eggs. These are laid in batches in damp places in the soil or under stones. A small replica of the adult emerges from the egg, and takes between 2 months and a year to mature. The activity of slugs and snails is highest in the spring and autumn. Slugs need to keep moist at all times otherwise they will dehydrate and die: thus they are nocturnal, and more active when it is wet.

GardenAdvice.co.uk suggests 6 steps to slug control in your garden

1. Soil conditions
Slugs need spaces to move through the soil; creating a good fine tilth will discourages them. Moving the soil surface with a rake in winter will expose many slugs and their eggs to frost damage.

2. Hygienic practice
Remove fallen and damaged leafs from your tender plants remember slugs eat decaying vegetation, so remove this source of food.

3. Encourage predators

Ground and rove beetles, centipedes, frogs and toads, slow-worms, hedgehogs and many species of birds all eat significant numbers of slugs. To encourage frogs and toads maintain a pond (without goldfish) and for slow-worms keep some long grass and avoid using a strimmer.

The Hedgehog Method:
Hedgehogs are predators of slugs so you need to attract them into the garden. At night time lay out dog food, which they love to eat - don't use bread or milk because it's bad for them. Once we've got them into the garden we need to keep them, so provide them with a water-proof box, about 18 inches long and 12 inches deep, fill it with straw so it's nice and snug, make it waterproof and hide it by covering it with leaves. Then the hedgehog can live in there. You'll not only get rid of pests, but, if you have children, they'll be delighted.

The Trench Method:
To encourage ground and rover beetles. Dig a trench about six inches deep and three inches across, and then line it with pebbles and Perspex edges. Beetles, which are a predator of slugs, will fall into the trench and can hide under the pebbles, which will protect them from birds. When the slug falls in, the beetle will have his dinner.

Parasitic nematodes
(Phasmarhabditis hermaphrodita) are available from Defenders Limited (01233 813121). These must be applied to the soil in solution. Be sure to follow the pack instructions. Treatment should be done in a block and the soil temperature must be above 5 degrees C.

4. Barrier methods:
Various materials or uncomfortable for slugs and snails to cross and a barrier provides some protection for vulnerable and valuable plants.

Vermiculite.Normally a compost addition vermiculite swells up with water, and we all know slugs love water, it actually moves which the slugs dislike. We've found vermiculite to be 90% effective as a control; we put it around the base of a plant in a ring. It's particularly good for plants that love water.

Gravel. The only gravel that works as a barrier is the crushed form because it has very sharp edges. Our favourite is horticultural grit 4 -8 mm.

Bark
Bark has a downside that in wet weather it can help the slugs travel to your plants. However in a dry season using a coarse bark made from large pieces is difficult for the slugs to move through because it becomes very dry.

5.Hand picking: Slugs can be collected at night with a torch. Traps can concentrate slugs to specific areas for picking. Traps can be made from glossy magazines, but old bits of carpet or old plastic plant trays make more effective slug traps. These provide a damp place to rest during the day and slugs can be removed in daylight. Such traps also provide refuge for ground beetles and centipedes that feed on slugs and their eggs. Using suicide plants to bring the slugs out of the soil for collection before you plant or sow your crop can also help to reduce numbers and restrict damage.

6. Trapping
If you need results quickly trapping is the method to opt for.

The Beer Trap Method: This is quite a traditional technique. All you need is a jar, put it on its side with a small amount of alcoholic beverage in it, and when slugs come along they'll drown in it. It's very simple, it's effective, and you don't need the whole can either.

Black plastic bag method: If you have a slug attack in one area in your garden this is a quick method to reduce the numbers . Take one black bin liner place on the ground in between your tender plants, then place inside two lettuce which are well pass there sales date. Finally add two tea cups of breakfast bran and pour a cup full of beer (bitter is best) over the lettuce. Leave over night with the top open and check in the morning, the slugs should have climbed into the bag over night and as the sun raises in the morning taken shelter in the bottom of the bag, ready to be removed from your garden.

Slug X: This is a slug trap that has been developed over a two-year period, using trials with cardboard boxes before the final plastic prototype was manufactured. The Garden Advice team presently have these traps under trial. More details can be found at www.westfield-products.co.uk
And finally, if you have both the space and the right environment then ducks and chickens are dual-purpose domestic animals that are great slug and snail hunters.


SuperDave replies...

Excellent suggestions Jo, thanks.

Got any suggestions for black fly?

Posted by: German Jo  | May 30, 2007 10:41 AM

SuziQ wrote...

Hi SuperDave
Having 'solved' the problem of slugs with blue pellets (I did opt for beer initially but I just felt as though I was treating them to a slap-up meal complete with alcohol!) I wondered if you could recommend anything for pigeons? I managed to turn them away from my cabbages with the help of netting, but now they've started on my root veg!

SuperDave replies...

Mmm, tricky. At the moment I can only suggest more netting, or even cages. Not very picturesque though (And I hate netting, currently trying to phase it out of my plot).

Some kind of bird scaring technique could be in order. My quick suggestion is CDs dangling on string, they twist and spin in the breeze and the reflected light freaks the birds out, apparently. I recommend you go to computer shops and take the free AOL cd's they flaunt so readily then string 'em up.

Mmmm, I feel a blog entry coming on........

Posted by: SuziQ  | June 12, 2007 12:48 PM

German Jo wrote...

SuziQ,

One suggestion I can put forward to eradicate pigeons, is.......

A couple of 'Alcaseltzer' tablets (Not too sure of the spelling)??? in some water. Pigeons will then have a drink, take flight and perform the amazing feat of 'Spontaneous Pigeon Combustion'.

Great to watch...

SuperDave replies...

Does this fall under the heading "humane"? Mmm? Mmm?

I couldn't possibly condone this..but, hehehe.

Oh, and do you want some tomato plants? Gardeners delight? I can take them along to tuesday football if required.

Let me know!

Posted by: German Jo  | June 14, 2007 7:58 AM

SuzQ wrote...

Hi SuperDave
Thanks for the suggestions - the CDs have to be better than my useless dog who only chases them once they've flown away anyway.
Thanks to German Jo too and although it sounds appealing, I'm more tempted to buy an air rifle and then eat them with a nice fresh garden salad.

SuperDave Replies...

Tasty, sounds much more sensible to me. Is the dog a good digger? He could be put to work that way maybe.

Posted by: SuzQ  | June 15, 2007 12:08 PM

SuziQ wrote...

Hi SuperDave
One question about the eco-friendly slug pellets - why do they go mouldy?
I scattered some (according to the instructions on the pack) through my veg beds but have since found that they've gone mouldy - particularly on my brassicas bed. I've also had to pick out some toadstools - I'm not sure if this is related. Any ideas?

SuperDave replies...

Hi Suzi, sorry to hear about your pellets.

I think the clue may be in the 'eco'. They are fairly natural products so they behave naturally. This appalling summer (recent weeks not withstanding) has made a lot of things go mouldy, not least all of my tomatoes. Mor of this in my nextish entry!

Posted by: SuziQ  | June 20, 2007 11:17 AM

Will wrote...

Further to hand picking - pick up slugs with some cheap tongs and drop them in a jar or tin can containing a concentrated brine. Don't need to put in too much brine - a quarter depth should do. Fill jar/tin with slugs. It's a faster death than you might imagine. Dispose of contents over a wall.

SuperDave replies...

Evil but effective Wil. I like it, but I'm not sure if your neighbours do!

Posted by: Will  | June 21, 2007 1:38 PM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Search this blog

April 2008
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30      
 

Older posts are in the Archives